Most FOIA requests fail for one of two reasons: they are too vague to search, or too broad to be anything but "unduly burdensome." A request that names systems, custodians, date ranges, and field-level detail is much harder to refuse.

The Steps

  1. 1
    Identify the right public body

    Each agency responds separately. A county sheriff, a state’s attorney, a circuit clerk, and a village police department are four different public bodies with four different FOIA officers.

  2. 2
    Name the system, not just the subject

    Instead of "all records about my case," ask for the specific system: the CAD event records, the warrant Event Log and Service Attempts tables, the case management audit log, the email of a named custodian for a stated date range.

  3. 3
    Give a date range and identifiers

    Include exact dates, case numbers, event numbers, incident numbers, and names. A searchable request is a request the agency cannot call unduly burdensome.

  4. 4
    Ask for the exemption log up front

    State that if any material is withheld or redacted, you request an itemized index identifying each redaction, the specific exemption claimed, and the segregability analysis.

  5. 5
    Request the format

    Ask for native or machine-readable format where records are electronic. A printed PDF of a database export strips exactly the metadata that makes the record useful.

  6. 6
    Send it in writing and preserve proof

    Email creates a timestamped record. Keep the sent message, any auto-acknowledgment, and the ticket number. Note the five-business-day deadline on your calendar.

  7. 7
    If the response is inadequate, escalate

    File a request for review with the Public Access Counselor within 60 days, attaching your request and their response and identifying precisely what was not answered.

What the Record Shows

  • A five-category request to Chicago OEMC produced a single address-search report returning zero rows. Category-by-category disposition is now the follow-up. See the response analysis.
  • A Sheriff’s draft FOIA response in this record was routed to the county’s civil litigation counsel before release. See the routing record.

Related pages